Thursday, January 21, 2016

Clinton Emails

With regard to emails on her server that were are the highest level of classification, in a recent NPR interview, Hillary Clinton stated: “Well, first, let me say that this is the continuation of an interagency dispute that has been going on now for some months. As the State Department has confirmed, I never sent or received any material marked classified, and that hasn’t changed in all of these months.” Like many Clinton statements, parsing is required. Clinton’s attitude is the result of a long standing systemic distrust between DOS and DOD characterized not by cooperation, but by competition due to a number of factors not to mention that the DOS budget is a fraction of the DOD budget. If you are at DOS you consider yourself the incarnation of "soft power" while on the other hand, DOD is clearly the instrument of war. These cultural differences are made dramatically manifest due to this latest Clinton scandal where DOD security classifications were viewed by DOS as being intrinsically DOD/Intel, and revocable by DOS. By the way, this interagency dysfunction brings the unfortunate Benghazi incident into a clearer perspective. 

1 comment:

Edgar Bates said...

As a follow up, there was an informative article posted War on the Rocks which doe a good job of underscoring the difference between how the Department of State and Department of Defense view classified material. The intel community promotes a culture where you can never be too cautious because many successful data collection activities are clandestine and most of the analysis occurs in secure facilities. This highly sensitive analysis is used to make high level decisions which are best done in secrecy. On the other hand the State Department does not operate in a classified environment. State Department officials conduct their diplomacy in unsecure locations such as embassies, restaurants, or over regular telephone lines so it follows that business conducted in a busy restaurant should not be considered classified. Whereas the intel community shuns the media, the State Department partners with the media to inform, persuade, and coerce foreign citizens and governments.

http://warontherocks.com/2016/03/were-hillary-clintons-emails-classified-where-you-stand-depends-on-where-you-sit/